Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Noura Bashshur's avatar

The comparison with abstinence-only education and school phone bans rests on a category error. Abstinence-only education failed for reasons specific to that policy: it withheld practical information about behavior adolescents would continue to encounter and left them poorly equipped to manage real-world health risks. School phone bans address a different mechanism. Smartphones provide continuous access to socially reinforcing, dopamine-driven reward loops that encourage compulsive checking, fragment attention, and compete with classroom instruction. Their value also extends beyond any immediate change in test scores.

Generative AI presents another distinct policy problem involving cognitive development, academic integrity, student data, tool design, and the delegation of intellectual work. Placing all three policies under the label of “prohibition” obscures the mechanisms that determine whether each intervention works. This seems to call for a “mu” response because the comparison itself lacks a sound premise. Your strongest evidence comes from the AI research comparing unrestricted GPT access with the guarded tutoring model, which directly supports policies tailored to specific uses, ages, safeguards, and learning goals.

Mark Loundy's avatar

Pushing the discussion home assumes that parents are broadly informed about the generative AI ecosystem—something that I suspect is generally not so. Although the LA and NYC district leaders *might* have read the same things about AI as you have, they are additionally subject to the political pressure of those same underinformed, and currently tech-panicking, parents.

45 more comments...

Ready for more?